Most OECD countries expect growing shortages of highly-skilled labour in the coming two
decades, and immigration is viewed as one way of addressing these. Most OECD countries have
introduced policies aimed at facilitating the recruitment of such workers in recent years and efforts along
these lines can be expected to continue. The document provides an overview of the issues related to the
management of highly skilled labour migration.
In general, migrants are perceived as highly skilled when they have at least tertiary education, but
other definitions are possible, notably on the basis of the nature of the occupation in which they are
employed. One practical way of defining highly skilled migrants that has been used in some countries is by
means of wages paid, with the highly skilled consisting of persons earning above a threshold value.
There are two principal ways of recruiting highly skilled workers from abroad. One is demanddriven,
through employer requests. The other is supply-driven and involves inviting candidates to apply
and selecting them on the basis of certain characteristics, among them age, educational attainment,
language proficiency and occupation, for which points are assigned. Candidates having more than a
threshold level of points are then granted the right to establish residence.
Supply-driven systems have been showing their limits in recent decades, with settlement
countries finding it more difficult to select for success in the labour market. Employers appear to attribute
less value to qualifications and work experience earned in a non-OECD country, so that immigrants
arriving without jobs are having a harder time finding employment commensurate with their qualifications
and experience.
One consequence has been a general trend towards transferring more of the responsibility for
selecting migrants to employers. In this way, any qualifications and experience issues are dealt in the
hiring negotiations between employers and workers prior to immigration. A second option is to favour
candidates for migration with qualifications earned in an OECD country and indeed, in the host country
itself. Most OECD countries have in fact introduced measures to allow international students to stay on
after they complete their studies, provided they can find work of an appropriate level in their field of study.
Some countries, however, do not have significant basins of native-speakers outside their borders,
so that hiring directly into jobs seems problematical, except in workplaces using an international language
such as English. For such countries, some direct recruitment may still be possible, if an international
language is widely spoken in the workplace. Otherwise supply-driven migration may have to be envisaged,
with significant investments made in language teaching for new arrivals.
Active recruitment means more than just facilitating work permits for employers or for aspirant
immigrants based on credentials. While high-skilled migrants may be attracted to countries with widely
spoken languages and high wages regardless of the obstacles, a country with moderate wages and its own
unique language will need to do more than just lower administrative barriers.
The effects of demographic change are only beginning to be felt in most countries. By 2010,
more than half of OECD countries will show incoming labour force cohorts which are smaller than
outgoing ones. The objective over the medium-term for OECD countries is to ensure the right scale and nature of movements to satisfy labour market needs. It would be premature to claim that all of the required policies are already in place.
Managing Highly-Skilled Labour Migration
A Comparative Analysis of Migration Policies and Challenges in OECD Countries
Working paper
OECD Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers
Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Abstract
In the same series
-
13 November 2024
-
Working paper27 September 2024
-
11 March 2024
Related publications
-
4 September 2024
-
1 December 2023